Penny Dreadful

Rachel Miner

Penny Deerborn

Mimi Rogers

Orianna Volkes

Chad Todhunter

Alvin

Mickey Jones

Eddie

Liz Davies

The Hitchhiker

Michael Berryman

Gas Station Attendant

Lucy Rogers-Ciaffa

Young Penny

Elyse Mirto

Penny's Mother (as Elyse Marie Mirto)